2 Strain Wave Mounts Battle It Out

If you’re deep into the world of astronomy, then you’re probably aware that precision is everything when it comes to tracking and imaging celestial bodies. This is where strain wave gearing comes into play, revolutionizing the way we look at the stars. But what exactly is strain wave gearing? In simple terms, it’s a highly accurate and virtually backlash-free gear system that greatly benefits astronomical mounts by offering smoother motion and more precise positioning of telescopes.

Why does this matter to stargazers and astronomers? The answer is straightforward: strain wave mounts can significantly improve your observational experiences by facilitating sharp, clear images. They counteract common issues stemming from gear inaccuracies, like the dreaded gear play that can cause your telescope to ‘jump’ during tracking or backlash, which causes pauses when reversing the declination gears from north/south or south/north.

Today, I’m going to be talking about two big players in the realm of strain wave mounts: the iOptron HAE29 Strain Wave AZ/EQ Dual Mount and the Sky-Watcher Wave 150i Strain Wave Drive Mount. These two mounts have been the talk of the town, and rightfully so, as they bring something unique to the table for amateur and professional astronomers alike. What’s notable is that both mounts are made by stalwarts in the astronomy gear arena, and both make many popular mounts, telescopes, and other instruments.

You’re going to find out about the features that make the iOptron HAE29 a versatile choice for those needing both Alt-Azimuth and Equatorial configurations. Plus, I’ll shed light on what sets the Sky-Watcher Wave 150i apart from its counterparts in terms of its strain wave drive system. Let’s kick off this stellar journey by diving into the world of the iOptron HAE29, exploring its tech specs, user experience, and why it might be the mount you’re looking to add to your astronomical arsenal.

Features of iOptron HAE29 Strain Wave AZ/EQ Dual Mount

I’m here to help you with a deeper look at the iOptron HAE29 Strain Wave AZ/EQ Dual Mount. Now, when I say this mount has features that astronomers dream of, I mean it. This mount integrates strain wave gearing, known for its precision and reliability, into a dual-mode structure that promises both Alt-Azimuth and Equatorial setups. That’s versatility at its best.

Choose something that resonates with you, and with the iOptron HAE29, that means getting to grips with its specifications and design attributes. With a solid build, it offers a weight capacity that’s impressive (without counterweights: 29.7 lbs (13.5 kg), with optional counterweights 44 lbs (20 kg), enabling you to attach a substantial payload without sacrificing stability or tracking accuracy.

Performance-wise, this mount is no slouch. Its GoTo system is powered by a sophisticated database and provides excellent object-tracking capabilities. Users are going to find out about a smooth operation that is almost silent, a real perk when you’re immersed in the quiet of the night sky.

I really hope that you appreciate the unique features that set the iOptron HAE29 apart. It’s not just about how much weight it can hold or how precise it is—it’s also about the ease with which it transitions from one configuration to another. This adds a layer of convenience for astronomers who enjoy both casual sky-watching and serious astrophotography. And the lightweight nature of strain-wave mounts makes them ideal for portable setups. On a final note, this mount comes with iPolar, which makes polar alignment a snap.

iOptron HAE29

Insights into the Sky-Watcher Wave 150i Strain Wave Drive Mount

The Sky-Watcher Wave 150i is another front-runner in the realm of strain wave drive mounts, known for its precision. Let’s dig into what makes this mount a worthy contender on any astronomer’s wish list.

First up, the technical specs. The mount boasts a patented strain wave gearing system that’s all about maintaining smooth motion while you stargaze. It has a payload capacity that is slightly higher than the iOptron (15 kg (33 lbs) without counterweights, 25 kg (55 lbs) with optional counterweights), making it a solid choice for heavy setups and serious skywatching. One downside is that the hand controller is optional, but if you purchase it the mount will be equipped with GoTo technology, giving you automated object tracking at the push of a button.

Now, how does it perform in the field? As of this writing, it has not been released, but the Sky-Watcher name means it is likely great in the field. Its setup process promises to be user-friendly. I am predicting the performance will be reliable, even during those long nights under the stars. The mount’s solid construction pairs with the innovative drive to reduce periodic error, which means clearer, crisper images for the astrophotographers out there.

One thing you can’t help but notice is the Sky-Watcher Wave 150i stands apart with its design. It’s not just about looks; this design contributes to reduced vibrations and greater stability, a big deal when you’re chasing perfect star trails.

Sky-Watcher Wave 150i

 

Comparative Analysis: iOptron HAE29 vs. Sky-Watcher Wave 150i

I’m here to help you with a head-to-head comparison of the iOptron HAE29 and the Sky-Watcher Wave 150i. It’s about breaking down the nitty-gritty of each to understand their capabilities and how they might fit into your stargazing adventures.

Design-wise, the iOptron HAE29 is a champ for versatility, flipping easily between Alt-Azimuth and Equatorial configurations. The Sky-Watcher, with its robust strain wave drive, targets the enthusiast seeking smooth tracking and quiet operation. Both are solid and attractive. Both have cable management designs, which is almost a necessity nowadays since the risk of running multiple cables that can get snagged increases with each new piece of equipment in the setup. And both mounts have “siblings” in the product lines, like the iOptron HAE43EC, which has a higher payload capacity and enhanced encoders for even more precise pointing and tracking, or the iOptron HAE29EC, which is the same as the reviewed model with enhanced encoders, and the Sky-Watcher Wave 100i, which is a more affordable version of the 150i with a smaller payload.

Verdict:

You can’t go wrong with either mount. As far as features, they are both similar. The Sky-Watcher has a slightly higher payload. But for the money, I would go with the iOptron because of the included hand controller and included object database and the iPolar for easy polar alignment. I hope that this has shed some light on the key differences and similarities between these two impressive mounts, making it easier for you to make a well-informed decision. Whichever you choose clear skies and great viewing!

 

Strain Wave Comparison

Feature iOptron HAE29 Sky-Watcher Wave 150i
Mount Type AZ/EQ Dual AZ/EQ Dual
Weight 8 lbs (3.6 kg) 5.8 kg (12.8 lbs)
Payload Capacity Without counterweights: 29.7 lbs (13.5 kg), With counterweights (optional): 44 lbs (20 kg) 15 kg (33 lbs) without counterweights, 25 kg (55 lbs) with counterweights
Right Ascension (RA) Drive Strain Wave Gear Strain Wave Gear
Declination (DEC) Drive Strain Wave Gear Strain Wave Gear
Slew Rates Max 8°/sec Max 10°/sec
Periodic Error (PE) Not specified Not specified (check user reviews for real-world performance)
Encoders Standard Standard
Autoguiding Port Yes Yes
Power Requirements 12V DC 12V DC
Optional Accessories Counterweight kit, iPolar electronic polar scope Counterweight kit, carbon fiber tripod
Power off braking Yes Yes
Tripod Optional Optional
Polar scope iPolar None
Cable Management Yes Yes
Hand Controller Included Optional
Saddle Vixen/Losmandy Vixen/Losmandy
Communication Wi-Fi, USB, Hand Controller Wi-Fi, Bluetooth
Price $2098 $2195

Leave a Comment